Beyond Expectations
On
the Pinot Noir Trail
in Oregon's Willamette Valley
By M.L. Lyke
This article was originally published in
The Washington Post, October 21, 2004
Reprinted with permission of the author |
We drove into Oregon wine country with wipers on intermittent, stereo
on low, expectations in check. A fine, soft rain blurred the outlines
of things -- the filbert orchards and grazing sheep, the slumping red
barns and old-timey storefronts, the rolling green pillows of land
and the acres of vineyards that climbed them.
I had come to investigate the region's celebrated pinot noir -- the
most elusive of wines, made from the fussiest of grapes, in this subtlest
of Northwest landscapes, tucked beneath layered blankets of low gray
clouds.
My traveling buddy was as clueless to the nuances of the grape as I was.
But we had a long weekend ahead of us to immerse and explore. The plan:
three days in the upper Willamette Valley wine region -- a mere 20 miles
from the heart of downtown Portland -- to sip and sample local delicacies,
and one day at the Oregon coast to walk off the damage.
Pinot noir was a wine I'd dismissed over the years in favor of big meaty
cabs, deep-throated merlots, two-fisted syrahs. I wanted a riot of red
to set my head spinning. I wanted full, fat, huge.
"Super-size me!" I might as
well have demanded when I walked into the wine shop.
How vulgar that all seems now.
Big Is Not Beautiful
In the most modest of Oregon wineries
-- converted warehouses, sheds, garages, little mom-and-pops set up in
old dairy barns -- I learned that "big" does
not necessarily mean "good."

David Lett, Eyrie Winemaker |
"Papa Pinot," the man who put Oregon on the international wine
map, practically spit out the "b" word when we visited his tasting
room. "I don't even make big wines. I don't believe in big wines," said
David Lett, a classical winemaker at odds with trends to power up pinot
in the cellar.
Even the big reds' fruit earns the scorn
of the wry man with the snowy white beard. "Pinot noir has small tight clusters. Cabernet is this
big dangly thing," said Lett, as he poured his Eyrie Vineyards pinot
noir inside the winery he and wife Diana created out of an old poultry
processing plant in the valley town of McMinnville.
I held up my glass and saw pink, not ink. And what swirled across my tongue
was something light and elegant -- a jazz pianist working a complicated
right-hand riff, sans bass.
It demanded time, and attention.
"People don't understand pinot noir," said Lett, "because
they have to think about it." It was a theme I would hear again and
again during our stay in the lush, hushed farmscape of the upper Willamette,
just west and southwest of Portland.
Once mocked as too wet, too cold and too muddy to grow a decent grape
-- suspicions deepened by early production of unimpressive jug and dessert
wines -- the valley now hosts an estimated 200 wineries. Land that sold
for $5,000 an acre in the late '80s -- when there were still only a dozen
wineries -- now sells for up to $13,000 an acre, and more than half the
valley's vineyards are planted in those misunderstood pinot noir grapes,
harvested by some of the most passionate winemakers in the business.
Jason Lett, David Lett's son, who is now vineyard manager for Bishop
Creek Vineyard and makes wine under his own Black Cap label -
his
daughter, Margo, David's granddaughter,
is already helping Dad
in the winery |
"If you spend any time in Oregon -- more than five minutes -- you'll
get in a discussion with a winemaker about clonal selection, soil types,
slope location, all those things," said Andy Perdue, editor of Wine
Press Northwest. "Oregon winemakers work as hard as anybody in the
world to find the exact right grape for the exact right spot."
The results can be stunning or, to the
uninitiated, confounding. "With
pinot noir, you either love it, or you don't care about it," said
Perdue. "But once you taste a great pinot noir, something clicks in
your head. You get it."
The Willamette Valley is no place for
pretense. Winemakers may race from field to tasting room to greet a visitor,
wiping dirt from their hands,
eager to talk and pour a favorite $40 reserve. During busy harvest seasons,
some pick alongside field workers and -- sweaty and hungry -- sit down
to devour a communal lunch, topped with a cool brew. "It takes a lot
of beer to make a little wine," quips Ned Lumpkin, co-founder of the
Carlton Winemakers Studio.
At the valley's small signature wineries,
vines are typically hand-picked, grapes hand-sorted, wines hand-crafted.
Lots are small, prices often premium.
We found $20 the average starting price for a good bottle. The cellar $12 "specials" we
tasted were mostly watery and flat. At $40, wines began to sing arias and
inspire philosophical meditations.
One tasting-room pourer, sniffing and
ahhing as she opened bottles, described pinot noir as a refined taste, "like dealing with the essence of the
wine rather than the wine itself -- the soul and not the body." Another
quoted a legendary line, attributed to French nuns, that pinot noir slides
down the throat as smoothly as "baby Jesus in velvet pants."
Minimalist Vintners
We began our wanderings with lunch at Bistro
Maison in McMinnville's historic
downtown. The pretty little restaurant offered such homemade delicacies
as fennel soup, sausage with local hazelnuts, cassoulet, quiche with shiitake
mushrooms. This wedding of French and Northwest sensibilities would become
old hat by trip's end.
After studying a map of wine country -- the guides are essential and available
at most stores, restaurants and wineries in the Willamette -- we began
our slow drive down winding two-lane country roads.
Carlton Winemakers Studio Tasting Bar
|
One of our first visits was to the Carlton
Winemakers Studio, the two-year-old eco-friendly, passive-solar co-operative
where small independent winemakers
share space, equipment and devotion to the vine. "When they get big
enough, they can set out on their own," said Kirsten Lumpkin, who
opened the studio in the historic former mill town of Carlton with husband
Ned and partners Eric Hamacher, of Hamacher Wines, and Louisa
Ponzi, winemaker
for Ponzi Vineyards.
Food and Wine magazine last year pronounced
the co-op "just plain
cool." Inside, visitors can taste winemakers' work in a light-filled
tasting room with a by-the-glass charge. A sampling menu offers such pampered
delicacies as leaf-wrapped, peppercorn-spiked goat's milk cheese soaked
in pear brandy.
In late afternoon, morning rains gave
way to what moss-backed Northwesterners call "partial sun" --
rays of light sneaking between peekaboo patches of blue in the sky. In
the distance, lifting clouds drifted silky
white fingers over hills ringing the valley. Below, the planted earth seemed
to steam a warm, wet sigh of happiness.
Or was it just me? Wandering from winery to winery, we had sampled pinots
that teased the mouth with hints of strawberry and black cherry, basil
and pepper, oak and cedar, earth and anise as we talked with winemakers
about their finicky little thin-skinned grape.
They described it in terms a psychologist
might use to diagnose a troubled child: temperamental, inconsistent,
fickle, unstable, volatile. "The
masochist's grape," some called it -- for good reason.
Although the Willamette has a pinot-friendly climate, it comes with no
guarantees. It is cool from winter to spring and warm in the late summer,
which can keep a precocious ripener from peaking early. But with an annual
average rainfall of 30 to 35 inches and erratic weather patterns, untimely
deluges can break hearts. One week's extra rain, one day's overripening,
one mistake in the harvest or cellar, and the wine can turn to junk --
raisiny and flabby.

Ken Wright and wife Karen, Sorting Pinot noir grapes
|
Even in benign conditions, the genetically unstable grapes can undergo
dramatic mutations, bearing fruit of varying size, shape and color, even
transforming from red grape to white, pinot noir to pinot gris.
It's a grape that demands attention,
but hates heavy handling -- which is why some hands-off winemakers in
the valley term themselves "minimal
interventionists."
"It's a gift of nature. Our job is to learn how not to get in the
way," said Ken Wright, one of the valley's most respected winemakers,
based in Carlton. His vineyard-designated Ken Wright Cellars pinots sell
out a year in advance and earn top reviews.
Wright got hooked on pinot noir as a
young waiter in Kentucky, sampling the great French Burgundies on his
restaurant's wine list. "I went
from drinking Lancer's and Mateus to that -- I was blown away."
He headed off to study viticulture at
the University of California at Davis. "I decided I wanted to make
wine my life -- to quit my pretend attempt to become a law student, do
what I really cared about, and not
care how it came out."
It came out well. Wright, a big-thinker
with a firm set to his jaw, is praised for helping bring consistency
to pinot noir production in the valley.
It began in the '80s, after three or four bad seasons of diluted grapes
and watery wine hit the market. Wright decided something had to change. "If
one person in New York tastes one glass of Oregon swill, we all suffer," said
Wright.
At the time, the standard contract with
growers was three tons of grapes per acre. Wright suggested winemakers
cut back to two, still paying the
full contract price. It was expensive, but fruit that remained on the vine
was better quality, with higher concentrations of minerals and sugar. "The
greater the load of fruit, the longer it takes to ripen," said Wright.
 |
Details: Pinot Noir Trail
GETTING THERE: The heart of Willamette
Valley wine country is less than an hour's drive from Portland,
Ore. United flies nonstop to Portland from Washington Dulles for
$478 round trip. From BWI, American, Delta and Continental offer
connecting flights, and Southwest has one direct flight per day;
all are charging about $235 round trip. Frontier, Continental,
America West, Alaska and American fly from Reagan National.
If you don't want to rent a car, a
number of tour operators will pick you up in Portland, or at your
hotel in the valley. Tour providers include Grape Escape Winery
Tours (503-283-3380, and
EcoTours of Oregon (888-868-7733).
Tours can get you into small boutique wineries you might not otherwise
see.
WINE COUNTRY: Pick up a winery guide,
available at most stores, tasting rooms and visitor centers, including
the Portland Visitors Information Center, 701 SW Sixth Ave. in
downtown Portland (877-678-5263). A downloadable version is available
from the Oregon Wine Board (www.oregonwine.org, 800-242-2363).
Wineries are typically open from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m., although some
open to the public only on Thanksgiving and Memorial Day weekends,
or by appointment. Calling ahead is always a good idea. Take cash:
Some wineries now charge tasting fees, especially for premium pourings.
WHERE TO STAY: We went for fanciful
Oregon funk, and stayed at the Grand Lodge in Forest Grove (3505
Pacific Ave., Forest Grove, 877- 992-9533, www.mcmenamins.com),
a former Masonic and Eastern Star Home renovated by the state's
famed McMenamin brothers, who've transformed schoolhouses and poorhouses
into artsy getaways with home breweries, quirky shops and playthings.
Accommodations for two people range from $45 per night in a bunk
bed to $185 for a king suite, with lodging packages available.
I loved the disc golf course and our room's homage to the inventor
of the Erector Set, but not the shared bathrooms and rattly radiator.
The McMenamins also own the Hotel Oregon in downtown McMinnville
(310 NE Evans St., 888-472-8427, www.mcmenamins.com), where doubles
start at $50 per night.
For luxuriating in the pastoral beauty
of the valley, many visitors eschew hotels for the goose-down,
homey, country pleasures of the area's many bed-and-breakfasts
and inns.
A favorite in centrally located McMinnville is the Youngberg Hill
Vineyards and Inn (10660 SW Youngberg Hill Road, 888-657-8668,
www.youngberghill.com), a spacious, romantic getaway that sits
700 feet above the valley, with decks to take in the sweeping views.
Rates are $139 to $169 double per night. Of course, visitors can
also stay in Portland, and take day trips to the wineries.
WHERE TO EAT: Chefs in the valley
tend to be as passionate and imaginative as winemakers, and restaurant
wine lists are long on local bottlings. Institutions in the valley
include Nick's Italian Cafe (521 NE Third St., McMinnville), where
the five-course prix-fixe is a must; entrees run about $19 to $24,
prix fixe $42. At Red Hills Provincial Dining (276 N Highway 99W,
Dundee), diners like to preface sumptuous feasts with seasonal
sesame-coated oysters with ginger aoli (entrees $20 to $26). The
Joel Palmer House restaurant (600 Ferry St., Dayton) offers a culinary
hallelujah to the edible mushroom, fresh-picked by the owners (entrees
$17.50 to $29.50). Tina's (760 Highway 99W, Dundee) turns fresh
seasonal ingredients from the valley into elegant French-Northwest
inspired creations; entrees $21 to $30.
-- M.L. Lyke
|
|
Fun and Funky
After a day of sipping, it was time for a good night's sleep, and choices
were plentiful. As wineries in the valley have multiplied, so have bed-and-breakfasts.
Visitors can stay in turn-of-the-century Victorians or colonials with orchards
and vineyards, go rustic in log lodges, or stay at friendly working family
farms.
We opted to forgo fancy in favor of fun and funk. The Grand
Lodge in Forest
Grove has its own movie theater, tavern, wine tasting cellar, soaking tub
and a 10-hole disc golf course that humbled any illusions I had about turning
Frisbee pro. Musicians' fiddling filled the halls, hung with historic photos
and offbeat portraits -- some life-size -- of former residents. Our little
corner room paid homage to the Oregon inventor of the Erector Set. That
was good. The shared bathroom with cold-to-lukewarm showers and the rattly
radiator were not. But rooms were only $85, and came with a hot breakfast.
We signed up for an official wine tour,
a good move on two fronts: It eliminated the dangers of what tour leaders
called "drifting and driving" on
the country roads, and it allowed for tours of small boutique wineries
we couldn't get into on our own.
One of our favorites was Freja Cellars, an estate boutique winery named
for the Norse goddess of love and fertility. It produces only 1,000 cases
a year. Tastings are in an outbuilding, with Oriental rugs thrown down
on concrete floor and plywood sheeting on walls. The wine itself was a
study in uptown elegance. We bought a bottle of 2000 Winemakers Reserve,
to save for the final leg of our journey: the Oregon coast.
Before we headed off, we made a final visit to Eyrie
Vineyards, and heard
firsthand the famed tale of David Lett and the infuriated Frenchmen.
For centuries, the people deemed most adept at handling the high-maintenance
pinot noir grape have been winegrowers in the Burgundy region of France,
which has the same sloping hills and cool climate as the Willamette Valley.
Legend is that invading Romans began cultivating the grape there in A.D.
1st century. Today, a French pinot from Burgundy can fetch thousands on
auction.
French Burgundy pours proud. So its
makers were not pleased when a young upstart from Oregon arrived at a
taste test in the '70s with a bottle of
some sort of stuff made by a bunch of down-on-their-luck hippies under
the weird label "Eyrie" in some wet corner of the United States
seemingly more acclimated to magic mushrooms than grapes.
The winemaker was Lett, who'd fallen
under the spell of French pinot noirs. Convinced Oregon could bring out
the best in the grape, he arrived in the
Willamette in the mid-'60s and started planting pinot noir vines, to the
amusement of practical-minded farmers selling sloped farmland cheap. "I
was 24 years old with 3,000 sticks of wood and degrees in philosophy and
viticulture. How could I lose?" said Papa Pinot.
How could he not lose? Bankers refused
to give David and Diana Lett a loan for their pioneering winery. So the
couple camped out at the vineyard,
sold textbooks to scrape by, found the old derelict poultry plant, and
went to work, naming their label after the nest, or "eyrie," of
a red-tailed hawk in their vineyard. "We were kids. We had this idea.
There was no reason to think it would work," said Diana.
It did, and David knew it. In 1979, he flew to the blind taste test in
France with bottles of their finest 1975 pinot noir. In that first blind-taste
test, he took third, outraging French contest organizers who challenged
him to do it again.
In the rematch of Old World and New, he came in second.
The Burgundian giant who put forth the challenge, Robert
Drouhin, led
the rush to the north Willamette Valley that followed over the next decades.
His daughter Veronique arrived stateside in 1986, apprenticing under Papa
Pinot and others. She now oversees one of the valley's premier wineries
on a 225-acre estate, producing under the Domaine Drouhin label.
We had a bottle of 2000 Domaine Drouhin pinot noir ("French soul,
Oregon soil") with a meal still etched in my senses at Tina's, a French/Northwestern
restaurant in Dundee that is a favorite of local winemakers, who are represented
in a 100-bottle-plus list of labels.
Poured in large crystal wineglasses that served as their own decanters,
the Domaine Drouhin was a swirl of suggestion: black cherry and spice,
leather and earth. It played beautifully with salads of fresh field greens,
local hazelnuts and shallot vinaigrette, and a rack of lamb in a port-garlic
sauce. Also recommended as pinot pairings were Tina's duck breast with
green peppercorn sauce and the braised rabbit legs, served with locally
harvested chanterelles.
Coasting Along
With heads and bellies full of new tastes, we turned the car toward the
Oregon coast late Sunday afternoon. The coast is a pretty hour-plus drive
from the heart of wine country, and often a wet one. Rain on the Pacific
is measured in feet, not inches -- think six-feet-tall -- and heavens oozed
down on earth as we drove past dense forests of alders and firs, their
branches padded with soft, hanging moss.
The Oregon coast stretches for miles
with massive wave-sculpted rocks called "haystacks" towering
just offshore. It's an unspoiled, access-friendly coast that invites
walking, and strolling into its veils
of gray mist, you feel as if you are wandering into a dream.
In the little beach town of Pacific
City, we checked into a motel across
the street from the main beach. From our balcony, we watched early-morning
fleets of flat-bottomed dories launch into the surf, headed out to fish
for halibut and ling cod on another afternoon of partial sun. Surfers and
ocean kayakers muscled into wet suits next to the fishermen. Dogs chased
Frisbees, kids built sand castles, teens scrambled up a massive sand dune
to slide down -- one daredevil on a snowboard.
We hit the beach, took off our shoes, put on sunscreen and hiked away
from the crowds, beachcombing for agates, sand dollars, shells, washed-up
bones of fish and seals and whales. Soon enough, we were all alone. The
rolling lines of surf broke into white froth, sending bubbly foam over
our toes. After two miles, I slumped against a log and let the warm sun
and cool marine fog hopscotch across my face.
My mind drifted back over the last few
days, and my slow awakening to an ethereal wine that defies ideas of
big, fat, full. I remembered a line
from a Rumi poem: "Let the beauty we love, be what we do." Surely
it was beauty that drove Oregon's pinot noir artisans to risk everything
for their maddening little grape.
| |
M.L.
Lyke loves wine, loves writing about it. Her last article
for the Washington Post was on Walla Walla. Read it here.
"It looks like the Wild West out
here in Walla Walla, like the kind of place where slow-talking
menfolk in dusty ten-gallon hats drink whiskey, not some fancy
fermented fruit drink served in high-falutin' crystal glasses
with skinny stems," she began.
M.L., a graduate of UCLA and Northwestern
Univesity, is a news writer with the Seattle Post-Intellingencer
and regular free-lancer for the Washington Post and other national
publications. She's broken stories on PCB contamination in orca
whales, dug into murder investigations and tried, real hard, to
catch a fish on a fly in the Louisiana delta. She reverted to bait.
She has won numerous awards for her writing, with judges commenting
on her "fresh ideas, original writing, and good, solid reporting."
She lives in the salty little town of Anacortes,
and can be reached at:
marylynn@wavecable.com
|
Hungry and happy, we decided to dine at a highly recommended, no-frills
little restaurant perched above a nearby river. It was called, simply,
the River House Restaurant. Fare was simple, too: off-the-boat fish, prawns,
buckets of fresh-dug steamer clams, served with a downhome, oven-hot loaf
of white bread.
We ordered halibut and paid a $7 corking fee to open our bottle of 2000
Freja Winemaker's Reserve. The halibut steak that arrived was huge -- a
platter filler -- and done with lemon, butter, dill. Period. This was nothing
to be messed with.
Each white bite was exquisite: moist, delicate, cooked to the exact millisecond
of doneness. I swirled the Freja in my glass, saw garnet down below, and
breathed in heady aromas of fresh berry and tea and toast.
I took a sip, closed my eyes and gave
thanks to "minimalist interventionist" chefs
and winemakers everywhere who believe less is more.
The pinot noir moved around on my tongue like a toe dancer in a complex
bit of choreography: raspberry here, currant there, a sprinkling of white
pepper. The finish was long, a rippling silk ribbon of pleasure.
It was sensual and lovely. I felt bathed in lightness.
I opened my eyes, smiled and nodded. I realized I had finally arrived.
Something had clicked. I finally got it.
M.L. Lyke writes frequently for The Washington Post's
Travel section.
|